Procedure: Buying a mold (b-mold-buying). Revision 7 — October 18, 2026. From Mike's notes: offshore risk, substitutions, picking a shop, the quote package, T1, the purchase order. Index: https://ancreationoffice.com/sop.txt Source: Mike's practice (Mike's notes, kept private). Lines marked "Mike" are his experience and opinion; "office" lines are the office's. Tier: deep. Read this when a mold is being quoted or bought, especially offshore. The tooling stage itself (design freeze to T1 and approval) is sop-tooling-loop.txt; qualification is sop-qualification.txt; molds classes and the quote package are in the library (plastics-mold-classes, aiag-ppap). 1. WHERE TO BUILD IT: CHINA OR THE US (Mike) - Quality is no longer the dividing line. Every Chinese mold Mike has looked at in about the last ten years was as good as an American one, and he has seen as many cheap molds come out of the US as out of China. Judge the shop and the mold, not the country. - The real watch-out with an offshore shop: they may run your mold, or a copy, to sell the part in other markets. In Mike's experience they are careful not to sell against you in your own market (made for the US, it stays out of the US, but may turn up in Australia). Short of a few toys, he can't think of a case where a copy came back into the US against a customer's product. - If you could never sell in those other markets anyway, weigh how much that risk really costs you. - The "free mold" trade-off: some shops build the mold for free or very cheap and make their money on the parts, and possibly on selling the part elsewhere. That was common in the 1980s and 90s. - Pay for the mold and the relationship is usually straight: with many US companies there now, most shops don't play those games any more (Mike). - Office: whether selling elsewhere matters depends on what the product's protection covers: a patent protects only in the countries where it is granted. Settle mold ownership, who may run it, and where it lives in the purchase agreement, and have the patent and contract questions looked at by an attorney (b-patent-prep, b-licensing). The office prepares the questions; it does not give legal advice. 2. SUBSTITUTIONS: THE REAL WATCH-OUT (Mike) - Shops, offshore especially, use "equivalents": the mold steel may not be the steel you specified; a bearing or bushing you specified arrives as a different one. - A steel certification (grade, hardness, specification) can be requested, but certificates are easy to forge, more so now with AI. Treat a certificate as a claim. Office: a hardness check on the delivered mold or inserts, by you or a third party, tests the claim without trusting the paper. - A substituted component is usually not a bad one: it is typically a part the shop already buys at a good price, used because yours couldn't be sourced. Ask for substitutions to be declared and approved before they go in (office). 3. PICKING A SHOP (Mike) - There is no great way to pick a mold shop on paper. You get comfortable with shops you work with, and you stay away from ones that burned you. - With a shop you don't know, especially far away or without easy communication: pick one already making nearly the same product. Many will sign up for anything whether they have done it or not. Making a faucet? Find a shop that makes good faucets (Alibaba sellers of that product are one way to find them) and ask whether they can make yours. That usually finds someone good, and also someone who could sell your faucet in another country without you knowing; weigh that (section 1). - Match the shop to the standard the part needs: high appearance and function, an automotive supplier; appliances, an appliance maker; power tools, a power tool maker. - In the US, visit. What Mike looks for on a visit: - Focus on the floor: is the work getting done right where it happens. - Clean, but not too clean. Mostly clean shows good work habits; a floor last painted six months ago, scuffed and used, is what a working shop looks like. Floors repainted for visitors means you pay for that in your mold. A shop that hasn't been cleaned since 1989 is a problem too. - Culture: a little friction is good. A shop where people needle each other about mistakes, with a master not afraid to tell a junior "no, that's not right", gets things right because nobody lets a mistake go. A shop where everyone is very polite and a mistake is okay tends to show it in the work: Mike has seen more screws left untorqued in the nicest shops. - Who runs the tool project: the best shops let engineers design the tools and promote an experienced toolmaker to project manager. A toolmaker knows what the person at the machine is doing and holds them to it, so the feedback is better. Engineers as project managers can work too (Mike has had good ones), but watch for an engineer who knows the CNC work less well than the machinist and goes easy on him. Ask who will manage your mold. - Why it works (Mike): for an engineer, project manager is often a stepping stone on the way to running the floor or the shop, so he tends to play it nice and not be seen as cranky. For a toolmaker who came up from apprentice to setup to programming, project manager is usually the top of his career. He is proud of getting there, takes personal ownership of every tool, and will hold everyone under him to it, because his reputation is what wins the customer who trusts him with the next big project. Ask how the project manager got the job and how long they have done it. 4. THE QUOTE PACKAGE (Mike) - Most quote packages are simple: the part (CAD), plus enough of the part's specifications that the shop understands it. Mike has sent out quotes with little more than the CAD surprisingly often, especially when the shop will also run the parts and you never take the mold. - What matters is the plant the mold will run in. Its standards go in the package: - Press platen sizes and ejector (knockout) patterns for the presses it will run on. - Water fittings, so the right ones go on the mold; circuit standards (for example, no long water circuits; sop-cooling-water.txt section 3). - If someone else will mold the parts, ask that molder for their standards and use them. - Steel: big tools are usually pre-hardened steel (too big to harden); smaller ones and inserts are hardened, with components at different hardnesses. The mold maker knows this as well as you do; say what you expect and check that you are thinking alike. You usually are. - Then hold a mold design review: water circuits, ejection, steel, before steel is cut. - Office: the mold class (Class 101-105, Plastics Industry Association guide, library: plastics-mold-classes) is a short way to state expected life and build level. 5. THE PURCHASE ORDER (Mike) - In a company, purchasing (usually the director of purchasing) already has standard terms for tooling. Follow them; they exist for good reasons. Getting creative with the terms doesn't help. - The engineer's job: qualify the vendor (purchasing can't judge a mold shop), and feed concerns to purchasing so they get written into the PO. Otherwise stay out of the paperwork; let purchasing place the PO. - Take concerns a couple of rungs up: to the director or senior manager of purchasing, who works with the lawyers and accounting and understands the contract. The buyer who processes the paperwork usually doesn't. - Office: an inventor or small company without a purchasing department doesn't have those standard terms. Then the office lists the concerns (mold ownership, who may run the mold, substitutions, payment milestones, T1 samples and approval, shipping, spare parts) for the person's attorney to put into terms (b-purchasing, b-business-manager). The office does not write contract terms. 6. THE T1 TRIAL (Mike) - Nine times out of ten, T1 asks: does it move, does it slide, can it run about 100 shots, does anything gall. - Measure some parts. - After it has run, run your hand over the mold: anything getting hot, anything starting to lock up. (Hot spots and uncooled moving parts: sop-cooling-water.txt.) - Office: process development and dimensional approval come after T1 (sop-scientific-molding.txt, sop-qualification.txt, sop-tooling-loop.txt). OPEN FOR MIKE - Nothing open.